Based on the Real Estate Agents Disciplinary Tribunal’s decision in Complaints Assessment Committee 2204 v Saini [2026] NZREADT 54 (2 November 2026), and LawNews coverage of it (16 November 2026).

A recent Tribunal decision is a reminder that what the agent knows about a house can matter as much as what your own building report says. Auckland agent Sapna Saini has been censured and ordered to pay about $38,000 in fines, compensation and costs. She failed to tell first home buyers about an invasive testing report that found serious weathertightness defects in the house they went on to buy.

What Happened

In early 2021 Ms Saini was the listing agent for a plaster-clad Auckland house. The vendors had a non-invasive building report that found no issues.

In April 2021 an earlier set of buyers made a conditional offer. Their inspector flagged possible weathertightness problems with the cladding, plus signs of moisture and decay, and recommended invasive testing. That testing found extensive decay at multiple sites and “serious weathertightness issues”. The report carried Ms Saini’s name, and she received and reviewed it. The buyers asked for $100,000 off the price. The vendors refused, and the buyers withdrew, citing the report.

Ms Saini did not upload either report to the agency’s record system or record why the sale had fallen over. She did not properly raise it with her branch manager, telling him the buyers were “just trying to get the property at a bargain”.

Two weeks later, first home buyers introduced by an agent from another branch signed up at $708,000. That agent knew nothing of the reports. The buyers did get their own inspection, from the same firm that had prepared the vendors’ clean report, and it found no weathertightness issues. The sale settled in June 2021.

The buyers only learned the truth in November 2021, when one of the earlier buyers knocked on their door.

The Tribunal’s Findings

The buyers complained to the Real Estate Authority in June 2022. Days before a two-day hearing in June 2026, Ms Saini admitted misconduct under s 73(b) of the Real Estate Agents Act 2008, meaning seriously incompetent or seriously negligent real estate agency work.

Her explanations shifted over the years. She first said she had not read the report. Later she blamed the other agent, the vendors and her branch manager. The Tribunal found those accounts were, for the most part, incorrect.

The Tribunal said she should have been alert to weathertightness risk. Her agency’s manual flagged it, and she had completed mandatory training on disclosure. In her favour, she had only four years’ experience at the time and no disciplinary history. The Tribunal did not accept that she could not afford to pay, noting she now works as a branch manager.

Order Amount
Censure —
Fine (maximum is $15,000) $10,000
Compensation to the buyers $9,993.50
Costs (40% of the Committee’s costs) $18,374
Total $38,367.50

Where the Compensation Fell Short

The agent was held to account, but the buyers recovered less than $10,000. The Tribunal accepted they would not have bought the house had they known of the risk. It still awarded only the losses they could prove:

  • $9,993.50 allowed for exterior plaster repairs, re-sealing and repainting, all backed by invoices.
  • About $5,000 declined for materials used on internal repairs, because there were no receipts.
  • An $80,922.63 re-clad quote declined. It was an estimate only, and the full extent of the defects had not been established.
  • No award for loss in value, because no valuation evidence was filed.

The larger claims failed, it seems, for lack of evidence. There was no proof that further repairs, such as a full re-clad, were required, or that the buyers had suffered a loss in value as a result of the agent’s conduct. This shows the need for accurate evidence of loss.

The Tribunal can award up to $100,000, but loss must be proved as it would be in court. A disciplinary complaint is not a substitute for a properly prepared claim. Depending on the facts, buyers may also have claims against the vendor, the agency or the building inspector.

What to Look Out For, and How to Protect Yourself

  • Ask the agent in writing. Ask whether any other building reports exist, and whether any earlier sale fell through and why. Agents must disclose defects they know about, and a written answer is evidence if things go wrong.
  • Choose your own inspector. Use someone independent of the vendor and the agent. In this case the buyers used the firm that had written the vendors’ clean report.
  • Know the limits of a visual inspection. With plaster or other monolithic cladding, a non-invasive report may not find hidden defects. Consider invasive testing before your agreement goes unconditional.
  • If you find defects after you buy, keep everything. Keep every invoice, receipt, report and email. A proper defects assessment and a valuation will carry far more weight than a quote alone.
  • Act promptly. Time limits apply to claims, and evidence is easier to gather while it is fresh.

If you have bought a property and found defects nobody told you about, get advice early. The longer it waits, the narrower your options become.