Commercial insurance

Commercial and construction insurance disputes

We advise businesses, construction professionals and property owners on commercial insurance, mainly where it arises from construction and building disputes: policy coverage, how exclusions apply, and claims insurers have declined. Michael practised for eight years at a leading insurance law practice.

  • Public liability
  • Professional indemnity
  • Coverage and exclusions

How we can help

When a claim is made against you

  • Public liability policy coverage for builders and trades
  • Professional indemnity claims against architects, engineers, designers and building inspectors
  • How exclusions apply to a building defect claim
  • Notifying claims and circumstances to your insurer

When you are claiming

  • Commercial claims declined by an insurer
  • Disputes over what a commercial policy covers
  • Body corporate and commercial building insurance claims
  • Claims against the insurers of liable builders and designers

Insurance in building and construction disputes

Most of our insurance work arises from building disputes. When a claim is made, builders, developers and designers look to their liability and professional indemnity insurers, and whether that cover responds often shapes the whole dispute. Owners and bodies corporate need to know it too, before they decide who to pursue.

We also act for owners and bodies corporate who have had to issue proceedings against insurers over leaky building claims.

If your insurer declines cover

  1. Get the reasons and the full policy

    Ask for the declinature in writing, with the policy wording and any endorsements the insurer relies on.

  2. Get advice on the declinature

    We review the insuring clause, the exclusions and the facts, and tell you whether the declinature is open to challenge.

  3. Put your case to the insurer

    Most coverage disputes are resolved by negotiation, with a clear statement of why the declinature is wrong.

  4. Proceedings, if needed

    Where the insurer will not move, we can issue proceedings in the District Court or High Court.

Commercial insurance: common questions

A claim has been made against my company. Will our liability insurance cover it?

It depends on the policy wording, especially the insuring clause, the exclusions and when the policy requires a claim or circumstance to be notified. Public liability and professional indemnity policies are often disputed on exclusions, such as those for defective workmanship or contractual liability. Notify your insurer promptly, and get advice before you accept or deny responsibility to the claimant.

Our insurer has declined cover. What can we do?

Ask for the insurer’s reasons in writing and a full copy of the policy, including any endorsements. We review the declinature against the wording and the facts, and advise whether it can be challenged. Commercial coverage disputes are usually resolved by negotiation with the insurer or, if needed, in court.

We are suing a builder or designer. Does their insurance matter?

Often, yes. Whether a builder, developer, architect or engineer has liability or professional indemnity insurance that will respond can decide whether a claim is worth pursuing, especially if the business is in financial difficulty. We consider insurance early when advising on who to claim against.

Can a body corporate claim on its building insurance for defects?

Building policies commonly exclude defective workmanship, design and gradual deterioration, so cover for defects is often limited, but sudden resulting damage may be covered. We act for owners and bodies corporate who have had to issue proceedings against insurers over leaky building claims.

Do you act on personal insurance claims?

No. Our insurance work is commercial, mainly arising from construction and building disputes. We do not act on personal claims such as house contents, motor vehicle, travel, health or income protection insurance.

These answers are general information, not legal advice for your situation.

Has your insurer declined cover?

Have the policy, the claim and the insurer’s letter to hand when you get in touch. We will tell you whether the declinature can be challenged, and the best way to do it.

We aim to reply within 24 hours. Every enquiry is held in strict confidence.

Other areas we can help with

  1. Defective & Leaky Buildings

    Claims for homeowners and bodies corporate since 2005, and defence of builders, developers, designers and their directors.

  2. Construction Disputes

    Payment claims, adjudication and building contract disputes under the Construction Contracts Act, for owners and contractors.

  3. Body Corporate & Unit Titles

    Levies, repairs, rules and governance disputes under the Unit Titles Act 2010, for bodies corporate, committees and owners.

  4. Commercial Litigation

    Contract disputes, misleading conduct claims under the Fair Trading Act, and claims against agents and professionals.